7 Excellent Crib Alternatives (With Pros and Cons of Each)


If you enjoyed this article, please consider sharing it with others!

Parents that are interested in skipping the crib altogether or just want to try something different with their baby should know that there are plenty of crib alternatives and substitutes available.

Finding the right crib alternative for you depends on the age of your baby and your preference as a parent. As your baby grows, her needs and safety requirements change. Most parents that skip the crib start with a co-sleeping system and move to bassinets, travel cribs, and floor beds. 

Depending on your situation, one of these alternatives might be just what you are looking for at this moment for your baby. If your baby isn’t here yet, that’s okay too! I’ll share my personal story of how we moved from one thing to the next.

Our story

My wife and I are on our third child and have another one on the way. With that said, we have had our fair share of experience with getting babies and young children to sleep and we’ve realized that there isn’t necessarily a one-size-fits-all solution for everyone out there.

Some folks might like to get their babies into a crib in the nursery as quickly as possible and maybe listen to a monitor. Other parents might want to keep the crib in their room. Perhaps you want the baby even closer so you put her in a bassinet by the bed. Still, other parents might skip the crib entirely and bed-share with the baby.

Personally, we’ve done it all.

With our first two children (twin girls), we followed a more traditional route. They started out sleeping in a bassinet next to the bed. Then, we moved them to a regular crib and pack-n-play to sleep in at night (we had to alternate them each night to be fair!) and napped in the cribs as well.

Our son, meanwhile, has been bed-sharing since he was born (he’s now about 18 months old) and we are starting to transition him to floor beds in our room. Eventually, we will transition him to his own room on a floor bed or a regular bed. Essentially, we’re skipping the crib completely with him and we haven’t missed it. Don’t get me wrong, by the way. We had a beautiful crib all ready for him that I painstakingly assembled and painted for him. We definitely didn’t plan on bed-sharing before he was born.

Despite that, we haven’t even used it.

What you choose is ultimately up to you. For breastfeeding moms, however, I will tell you that my wife loved having the baby right there next to her in the bed to keep nighttime disruptions to a minimum.

Whatever reason you are looking for a crib alternative, be it saving money, parental preference, or even safety, there are plenty of options for you to choose from. Remember that you can start with one option and move to others over time as your baby’s needs change!

By the way, I’ve written a whole article on reasons to skip the crib that you can check out here. It goes into much more detail and highlights some of my personal story as well.

The Best Crib Alternatives

Here is a list, in no particular order, of some things that you can use instead of a crib to help your baby sleep at night and during naps. I’ll add my personal experience, pros, and cons of each option as well as a recommendation to get you started on your search!

Floor beds

Instead of worrying over a crib, fancy pack-n-plays, or bed-sharing, you can simply use a floor bed.

This is as simple as it gets!

A floor bed is really just a mattress that you put a fitted sheet on for your baby to sleep on. If you use this system, you will need to be sure that the room your baby is sleeping in is entirely baby-proofed because there won’t be anything stopping them from getting out of the bed at night. Current sleep recommendations mean that you shouldn’t have any blankets or pillows on the mattress until your baby is older, and you should be sure that the mattress isn’t too thick in case your baby were to roll off. Be sure there is a soft carpet or a thick rug on the floor underneath the mattress.

Personally, I would recommend getting a pack-n-play insert mattress like the one pictured above. These are amazing because you can fold them up and move them out of the way during the day, move them to another room, or even throw it in the car for a trip. This particular mattress is double-sided to provide the firmness that a newborn needs and the softness that a toddler will love. It also comes with a great zip-on cover that is machine washable, waterproof, stain-resistant, antibacterial, and hypoallergenic.

It’s also super affordable.

I seriously wish that this mattress had been available when we were shopping! Check it out right here (and read some of the awesome reviews on Amazon).

Pros:

  • If you have a suitable old mattress, then you won’t have to spend any money
  • Can last for many years as your child grows
  • Easily moved from one room to another
  • Add pillows and bedding once your baby is past the age of SIDS risk.

Cons:

  • Baby could roll off the bed – works best for older babies
  • The room must be totally baby-proofed to ensure safety
  • Keeping older babies and toddlers in bed could become challenging

Putting a co-sleeper in the bed

A co-sleeper is a much cheaper alternative to a bassinet or crib for allowing your baby to co-sleep and even bed-share with you safely. Essentially, these are little bassinets that sit directly in the bed and provide a safe sleeping surface for your baby while helping to prevent mom and dad from rolling over onto the baby at the same time.

These are great because you get all of the perks of using a bassinet without most of the drawbacks. Plus, you can easily move a co-sleeper around the house and into different rooms for your baby to sleep. Heck, you could even move your baby in it while she is sleeping!

This particular co-sleeper checks all of the necessary boxes for safe sleeping and it’s super affordable to boot!

It has a sturdy metal frame, but it only weighs about six pounds so you won’t have to throw your back out to move it around. The fabric of the mattress is naturally fire-resistant, and the mesh around the sides makes it breathable. Overall, co-sleepers like this are super handy to have around and provide peace of mind while your baby sleeps.

You can check out what other parents think about this product here.

Pros:

  • Affordable
  • Lightweight
  • Easy to move around the bed or house
  • Allows safer bed-sharing

Cons:

  • Included sheets and pad are not waterproof
  • Your baby will outgrow it at around six months old
  • Takes up space in the bed (probably need a queen or larger)

Travel cribs

These cribs are meant to be easily collapsed and packed up so that you can easily take them wherever you happen to be going. They are pretty simple and no-frills compared to most cribs or pack-n-plays, but really, you don’t have to complicate things too much to get your baby a good night’s sleep!

The best thing about travel cribs is that they are super lightweight, easy to carry, and usually fit inside a backpack or small carrying case. Since babies can be very temperamental about sleeping in new places, it is also amazing to be able to keep her with the same bedtime routine in a bed that she feels comfortable and safe inside.

Although I haven’t personally used this particular model, it checks all of the boxes that I would love to have in something that I buy for my baby. Most importantly, it is GreenGuard Gold certified, which means it has no lead, phthalates, PVC, heavy metals, or other toxins. I believe this might be the only play yard that I’ve seen with this certification. It is also a zippered side, a mattress approved for overnight sleep, it’s lightweight, and it fits into a handy backpack. The only real downside is that it does not come with sheets. It isn’t cheap, but you will also get what you pay for, and you’ll be able to use it for many years as your baby grows.

Check out this travel crib right here (and see the highly-rated reviews from other parents like you on Amazon!)

Pros:

  • Can last for years
  • Portable and easy to use while traveling
  • Easy to move around the house or even bring outside
  • GreenGuard Gold certification

Cons:

  • Not cheap (but still less expensive than most cribs)
  • Doesn’t come with sheets or a mattress cover (available separately)

Pack and plays

Your standard pack ‘n play is similar to a travel crib in that they are meant to collapse and move around pretty easily. They usually trade some of the portability and convenience of a travel crib, however, for a few more features and a sturdier design.

It’s pretty common to find pack and plays with built-in bassinets, changing tables, storage areas, mobiles, and more. This makes them great for crib substitutes because they can offer pretty much the same sleep performance of a crib but with more features at a similar or even cheaper price. You can also break everything down and bring the pack ‘n play to grandma’s house as well. Typically, they will be made with metal frames with fabric material covering it and they will have mess sides for breathability.

This particular product from Baby Trend is affordable and has just enough features for me without getting too complicated. It has a built-in bassinet that you can place alongside your bed (if you have space) along with an organizer for your diaper-changing supplies. If you are done with the bassinet, you can simply remove it to get a full-size bed. The whole thing is on wheels so you can move it around the room easily, but you’ll have to collapse it to move it any serious distance because it’s unlikely to fit through a doorway.

Check out this pack and play right here (and see other reviewer’s impressions on Amazon).

Pros:

  • Affordable
  • Most have a bassinet feature
  • Reasonably portable
  • Easy to find one with the features you want most
  • Standard sizes allow you to use your own mattress if desired
  • The closest alternative to a traditional crib

Cons:

  • Some liners are not removable for cleaning
  • Some models are a little difficult to collapse on your own
  • Could be too heavy to move around for new mothers

Bassinets and bedside co-sleepers

I mentioned earlier that co-sleepers are a great alternative to bassinets, but I still want to mention these because they might work well for your situation and I’ve personally used one with my son.

There is a range of styles among bassinets, but most of them are designed with a sturdy (and heavy!) base along with a mesh-sided sleeping area up top. Most of them are designed to be rolled or moved up close so that the sleeping area hangs over your bed. Many also have a way to lower the side down quickly so that you can get your baby out more easily while lying in bed.

One thing to note about bassinets, in general, is that you shouldn’t use them once your baby is old enough to push up or roll over because it opens the door for them to climb up and out of the sleeping area. Since bassinets are usually high off of the floor, this is a potentially big concern!

In fact, that’s the biggest downside of bassinets, in general. You won’t be able to use them for too long before it’s time to move on to something more age-appropriate. That means you have about six months, at the most!

I can personally recommend the HALO line of bassinets because we have used one with my son. The particular one that we got is very similar to the one pictured above and I can tell you that I was surprised at just how sturdy and heavy the base is for the unit. There is really no risk of the bassinet falling over under normal circumstances. It has a swivel that lets you move it over the bed or away, the top bedding is firm, the sides are made from breathable mesh, and the side closest to the bed easily pulls down to grab your baby when needed for nursing.

If you want to check this unit out, you can do so here (and read reviews from other parents on Amazon).

Pros:

  • Sturdy construction
  • Swiveling top makes it easy to reposition
  • Easy to get baby in and out of the bassinet while in bed

Cons:

  • Your baby will grow out of it relatively quickly
  • Some models are quite expensive
  • Heavy base makes it difficult to move around the house

Bed-sharing

This is actually the option that my wife and I have used the most with our third child. Since he was breastfed, letting him stay in bed with us meant that it was incredibly easy for my wife to feed him throughout the night, and she didn’t have to fully wake up and walk across the house to calm a crying baby. She also felt a peace of mind having him in the bed because she could instantly check on him whenever she wanted.

I should point out that even though we had great success with this method personally, it is actually not recommended by the AAP because of the potential SIDS risk. Ideally, newborns sleep on a firm mattress without any blankets or pillows that could increase the possibility of suffocation. Additionally, parents could easily roll over onto their children and smother them.

In our particular case, my wife is an extremely light sleeper and we both rarely move much while we sleep. She was able to comfortably position our son in between us without any blankets or pillows nearby.

With that being said, the safest option for bed-sharing is really to use the co-sleeper that I mentioned above to minimize the safety risk as much as possible!

Pros:

  • Nothing to buy
  • Instant feedback from your newborn when it comes to feeding
  • Peace of mind for some mothers

Cons:

  • Potential safety hazard
  • Takes up space in bed (need a queen-size or larger)

Cardboard box

Okay, I added this one for a little bit of a laugh, but this is actually a serious option for some people!

In Finland, it is quite common for hospitals to send new parents and babies home with what they call a ‘maternity package’ which is provided by the government. The package includes things like shampoo, lotion, clothes, diapers, wipes, and other essentials to use for your baby. All of those items are then loaded into a sturdy cardboard box with a small mattress in the bottom that can work as a little crib or bassinet.

It’s a pretty cool tradition that dates back to the 1930s and is meant to ensure that all babies get an equal start in life regardless of their financial situation. The boxes were also tied to receiving the care of a doctor and, combined, helped drastically reduce the infant mortality rate in Finland over the years.

At least one company wants to make this tradition possible outside of Finland, so if you are interested, you can check them out at Finnish Baby Box here.

If you enjoyed this article, please consider sharing it with others!

Josh

I'm the dad in charge of Natural Baby life. With 10 years of parenting experience across three children, I am constantly learning how to raise children more naturally. I'm passionate about doing whatever it takes to raise a happy and healthy baby! Find out more about me here.

Recent Content